Immigration Attorney for Y Combinator Startups Hosts AMA: Key Takeaways for Founders
In a highly anticipated Ask Me Anything (AMA) session, Peter Roberts, a prominent immigration attorney who advises Y Combinator and numerous startups, addressed critical visa challenges facing entrepreneurs and employees. The six-hour session on Hacker News drew 109 points and 173 comments, with Roberts fielding questions on everything from H-1B caps to O-1 visas and the realities of starting a company without permanent residency.
Roberts emphasized the urgency of understanding U.S. immigration pathways early. “One of the most common mistakes founders make is assuming they can simply work on their own startup on a tourist visa,” Roberts cautioned. “That’s a violation of status and can jeopardize future applications.” He also noted that many founders overlook the EB-1A extraordinary ability category, which can be a faster route to a green card for those with strong traction.
Key Takeaways from the AMA
1. Visa Options for Startup Founders
Roberts highlighted that the O-1 visa is the most viable for founders with significant press, funding, or awards. “A solid O-1 petition can be approved in weeks if the evidence is compelling,” he said. For earlier-stage founders, the H-1B lottery remains a gamble, but those who work for their own startup—while holding equity—face extra scrutiny.
2. The H-1B Trap for Entrepreneurs
“A founder who’s also the H-1B beneficiary needs to prove there’s a valid employer-employee relationship, which is tough when you own the company,” Roberts explained. He recommended using a separate entity or a professional employer organization to maintain compliance.
3. Canada as a Backup Plan
Roberts acknowledged the growing trend of founders moving to Canada via the Global Talent Stream. “It’s not ideal for everyone, but it gives you a two-year work permit while your U.S. case progresses,” he noted. He added that many YC founders use this as a bridge while building their U.S. credibility.
Background
Peter Roberts has been a staple in the startup immigration world for over a decade. He has worked directly with Y Combinator, providing guidance to portfolio companies on visa strategies. His AMA threads on Hacker News have become a quarterly resource for founders, engineers, and investors navigating the labyrinthine U.S. immigration system. Previous threads are archived on his profile page, covering topics from EB-1 to J-1 visas.
The most recent AMA was no exception—173 comments in six hours meant Roberts had to prioritize questions that benefited the broadest audience. “I can’t offer specific legal advice without full facts,” he reminded readers, “but I can clarify common misunderstandings and share patterns I’ve observed across hundreds of startups.”
What This Means
For Y Combinator and the broader startup ecosystem, Roberts’ AMA underscores a harsh reality: immigration hurdles are often the biggest bottleneck for non-U.S. founders. Even with strong venture backing, a visa denial can force a company to relocate or lose key talent. The session served as a wake-up call to start planning early—ideally before applying to an accelerator.
“By the time a founder is in YC, we’re often racing against the clock to find a viable visa path,” Roberts said. “The earlier a founder consults an attorney, the more options they have.” With the H-1B lottery odds dropping below 20%, the O-1 and L-1 (intracompany transfer) routes are becoming increasingly important. Roberts predicted that more startups will leverage remote teams and foreign subsidiaries to circumvent U.S. visa limits.
Internal Links: